» Cdreviews  
« back

Within Temptation - Mother Earth


*
=Staff's pick

Mother Earth*
Ice Queen*
Our Farewell
Caged
The Promise
Never-ending Story
Deceiver Of Fools*
Intro
Dark Wings*
In Perfect Harmony
Restless (bonus track)
Bittersweet (bonus track)
Enter (bonus track)
The Dance (bonus track)


Genre Opera Metal
Sharon den Adel
Vocals
Tracks 14
Robert Westerholt
Guitar
Runningtime 76 Min.
Ruud Jolie
Guitar
Label GUN
Jeroen van Veen
Bass
Release 07 June 2003
Stephen van Haestregt
Drums
Country Holland
Martijn Spierenburg
Keyboards
Similar artists Nightwish, Epica, Edenbridge, Lacuna Coil

The album starts beautifully with the title track Mother Earth with a great drum driven rhythm and with a powerful melodyline played by flute, and when the singing begins I find myself being embraced by this wonderful music. This continues with the second track Ice Queen that also is a midtempo paced track and equally beautiful as the first one.

And if all tracks could have been this great this would have been a masterpiece, Sharon den Adel has a really great voice that is a mixture of the opera characteristics of Tarja from Nightwish and the frailness of Kate Bush (English pop-artist that had her peak in the eighties with songs like: Running Up The Hill and Wuthering heights). That voice combined with the music that has a gothic sense to it makes sure that the possibilities are definitely there in order to make a great album.

But as in many cases the album doesn't hold up in quality through the ten songs ( I doesn't include the bonus tracks in my review), the orchestral influences takes over far too much at times, it feels like it has been to overdone. And than there is the ballads, they are a bit too "sweet" for my taste, I really enjoy this kind of music when you have a flow in the rhythm as it is backed up by an orchestra, but when is loses speed it also often loses my interest.

My two favourite tracks are Deceiver Of Fools that starts slow and beautifully orchestrated to then pick up the pace in the chorus to a powerful midtempo song in the vein of Nightwish, the other one is Dark Wings that is the most straightforward and fastest track on the album.

The orchestration on the album gives a nice depth to the music and you get a concert hall feeling by listening, but it gets a bit too much after awhile when the tempo is slowed down. As beautiful and soothing the music of Within Temptation might be it is not an album to "get metal" to, but I'm quite certain that Mother Earth will be played in my headphones several times when I'm hung over or just want to relax for a moment.

See also review of: Let Us Burn - Elements & Hydra Live In Concert , The Heart Of Everything

Production
Vocals
Compositions

8

9

5

 
Summary



6 chalices of 10 - Thomas

Related links:

www.withintemptation.com