To take in consideration
Written by Mat, December 2005
ver
so often we stumble on a reviewer that criticizes the band in question
for lack of originality and for sounding too much like band x or y. But
let's stop right there for a minute and really think things through. Here
we're dealing with a bunch of people in a band who are doing what they
love and most certainly put their entire heart, mind and soul into their
music and compositions. And it all most certainly also began with them
having their own musical favourites growing up and then decided to grab
an instrument and start to learn it.
f
course this would lead to that when their skills increased they also doubtlessly
began playing their favourite bands' songs. Eventually some even formed
their own bands and decided to really make a name for them. With this
in mind it should of course be a very natural consequence that their own
musical direction and compositions will have certain influences from these,
more or less evident from case to case. And come on people, we all know
that where there are leaders, there are always also followers. And I say
as long as those followers don't copycat their role models and compose
dead on Xeroxes I think we reviewers should be a little more tolerant
on this topic. It feels especially actualized in these days when there
are hundreds of metal bands around in a genre quite narrow as it is and
it's as good as impossible not to sound like or remind of anything else.
know
I am very guilty of this myself but I will for sure at least try to be
more tolerant further on, because giving a worse grade only on behalf
of this is actually very unfair, a consequence of not seeing the entire
picture and also used a little too often to really suit me. Let the bands
play what they like because what do you think would happen if the musicians
begin to sidestep their own backyards in search for a sound more original
just to please some opinion makers?
'm
100% dead sure they would compose way worse music and probably end up
not loving what they once did anymore and that's not a situation I think
we want. After all it's the music and the songs that are most important
and what we should focus the absolute most upon so I urge you other reviewers
and also readers to be a little more considerate and more forgiving in
this matter in your coming opinions and purchases.
Mat - December 2005
|